Coverage spread: 2 sources — 2 right
Lean ratings via AllSides / Media Bias-Fact-Check. How this works.
Seattle Storm co-owner Celeste Keaton has been fined and suspended from the team’s next five home games by the WNBA after two teenage fans accused her of berating them during a July 29 game against the Indiana Fever at Climate Pledge Arena in Seattle, which the Storm lost 105-95. The girls, seated courtside and wearing apparel from XX-XY Athletics — a company founded by former gymnast Jennifer Sey that says its mission is to protect women’s sports and spaces — were holding a sign reading “Thank you, Sophie for speaking up for girls!” in support of Fever guard Sophie Cunningham’s recent public comments opposing transgender women competing in women’s sports.
According to the girls’ account, given to independent journalist Brandi Kruse on her Undivided podcast, Keaton approached them, invoked religion by saying “Jesus loves everyone,” then allegedly told them she hoped “Jesus can forgive you for what sin you’ve done” before calling them “f—ing insane” while pointing at her head and saying “God can save you.” One of the girls said she was left in tears, telling Kruse she had faced online hostility before but had never been screamed at in person, and had not expected the confrontation because she assumed Keaton would be friendly. The girls also said they felt uneasy throughout the night, describing nearby fans turning their backs and physically distancing themselves.
Cunningham’s response and the Storm’s apology
Cunningham addressed the incident on X the following night, calling Keaton’s conduct “truly embarrassing” and saying it reflected poorly on her as a leader. She wrote that she believes there is “a safe space and love for EVERYBODY,” listing “biological girls, biological boys, trans women, and trans men,” and said people can disagree while still being kind. She praised the two girls for “standing up for what they believe” and indicated she planned to send them gifts. Storm majority owner Ginny Gilder issued a statement apologizing for Keaton’s remarks, saying the organization is “aware” of the comments made to the two fans, apologizing that it happened, and affirming a commitment to making every fan feel welcome and respected.
Wider context of the night
Fox News reports that the confrontation was part of a broader charged atmosphere around the game. A rally supporting Cunningham’s stance was held outside Climate Pledge Arena beforehand, met by a smaller counter-demonstration of transgender-inclusion advocates. Kruse, who said she helped organize the pro-Cunningham gathering and accompanied the girls into portions of the game, claimed she witnessed Storm players making mocking gestures toward the two fans. Separate video footage circulated showing the girls in an additional confrontation with another fan at the game, which added to the online attention the story received. Author J.K. Rowling and other high-profile social media figures amplified the girls’ account, contributing to the incident’s rapid spread.
How the coverage compares
The New York Post and Fox News largely align on the core facts: Keaton’s alleged remarks, the WNBA’s fine and five-game suspension, Cunningham’s public rebuke, and the Storm’s apology. Both outlets rely primarily on the girls’ account as relayed through Brandi Kruse rather than on direct, independently verified statements from Keaton herself, and neither article includes a detailed response or denial from Keaton. The Post places more emphasis on Cunningham’s full statement and on quoting the girls at length about how frightened and shocked they were, including their sense of being ostracized by other attendees during the game. Fox News, by contrast, devotes more attention to the broader atmosphere around the event — the dueling rally and counterprotest outside the arena, the alleged mocking gestures from Storm players, a separate filmed confrontation with another fan, and the amplification of the story by J.K. Rowling — framing the courtside incident as one flashpoint within a larger night of tension. Fox News also notes that Cunningham’s stance had recently drawn a defense from the White House, a detail not present in the Post’s account, suggesting the story has drawn political attention beyond sports media.
Why it matters
The episode underscores how the debate over transgender participation in women’s sports has spilled directly into WNBA arenas, implicating not just players and league officials but team ownership. Cunningham’s earlier public comments, made in an ESPN interview, had already made her a focal point for advocates on both sides of the issue; she has said her position is not rooted in hostility toward transgender people but in a desire to protect what she considers fairness in women’s sports. The WNBA’s decision to fine and suspend a team co-owner over remarks to fans signals that the league is treating the confrontation as a serious conduct issue, while the Storm’s public apology reflects an effort to manage reputational fallout. With minors involved, videos circulating widely, and prominent commentators like Rowling weighing in, the incident has become a flashpoint illustrating how contentious and personal this broader cultural debate has become at the fan level, not just among athletes and officials.
Sources
Featured photo: SounderBruce via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)